Atlantic Fish Restaurant Review Boston Massachusetts
When I was in Boston just recently, I met up with a friend of mine for some dinner one evening. Of course I suggested the Royal Bengal (click here for the article), but she wanted nothing to do with Indian Food as she was slated to run the Boston Marathon in a couple days, and she didn’t want to risk the Indian food having adverse affects on her system prior to the race. I can appreciate that, because sometimes Indian food affects everyone differently if you know what I mean!
She told me about this trendy popular place called Atlantic Fish; a fine seafood restaurant. She had dined here a number of times in the past and vouched for the quality of this place. I was up for some seafood as I hadn’t had any yet this trip and numerous people told me to get some good seafood while in Boston. Being right on the East Coast of the United States, the chances are pretty good that the seafood would be good. After all Boston is famous for the Boston Clam Chowder right?
Atlantic Fish is located right downtown in Boston at 761 Boylston Street, Boston Massachusetts - 617-267-4000. Click here for the Atlantic Fish website . Click here for the Google Map.
You can definitely tell the restaurant is a bit more upscale from the fancy decor on the outside of the restaurant and being right downtown on a main street, I am sure the rent is not cheap.
 
When you walk in the restaurant, the smell of the food is the first thing that catches your senses. This is one of those places that is busy all the time. When we entered this one evening, the restaurant was packed with lots of people seemingly having a good time. There was lots of laughter and smiles from all the patrons everywhere. The atmosphere was definitely contagious.
My friend and I choose to sit in the “lounge/bar” area as we really didn’t want to wait 1/2 hour for a normal table. The bar table was pretty much like a normal table as we were seated at an elevated rectangular table that would easily fit 4 people utilizing the bar height chairs. I took a look around the restaurant and the finishing in the restaurant was impeccable. The classic timeless decor of rich colored hardwood throughout accented by the soft dim yellow glow of the lights above definitely gave this restaurant a very friendly, warm and inviting atmosphere. The bar area was pretty impressive and the restaurant seemed to be able to hold from 100-200 people would be my best guess. The best way to describe this interior of this restaurant is it resembles a dining room of that of a cruise ship. If you have been on a cruise in the past you know what I am talking about, if you haven’t then go on a cruise some time…you won’t regret it!

We decided to get a number of appetizers and salads for our meal as we were both not very hungry. We ended up each getting a Toasted Goat Cheese Salad, I got a Butternut Squash Soup, and we shared a Calamari and an Ahi Tuna appetizer plate, plus some dessert. Â
The Bread
You know it is a good omen, when the bread they bring you before your meal is so good that you need to ask for another basket. The bread was awesome! Freshly baked, nice and soft, full of flavor along with the sesame thin wafers were a great prequel to dinner.

Butternut Squash Soup
Made fresh in house, this butternut squash soup has to be one of the best squash soups I have ever had. The soup was very smooth, with all the flavors and spices blending together perfectly to give you that hearty full flavored experience. The soup was also served to me hot which is always a bonus. I have been to many restaurants where they serve the soup luke warm or cold and that totally takes away from the true essence of the soup. Restaurants that serve hot food hot and cold food cold are definitely taking a step in the right direction.

Calamari Milano
It is interesting how restaurants around the world do their calamari. I have had many different versions of Calamari and some are good and some aren’t. Described on the menu as: “Tossed with olive oil, hot peppers, parmesan and garlic served grilled or fried with a warm pomodoro sauce” the description definitely sounds good.
The calamari milano here at the Atlantic fish looked and tasted like a tender small California bay calamari in a light crisp batter. The dish was definitely good, but would I call it some of the best I have ever had? well no, but don’t get me wrong, it wasn’t bad either. I would order it again, I’m just saying it wasn’t unique and memorable enough for me to rant and rave about it and tell someone to go out of their way to head to Atlantic Fish and order the dish. Maybe it was the pomodoro cocktail sauce that made it just OK.
I just think that if you are going to do a memorable calamari dish, you need to do it and serve it with some other signature sauce than just a standard issue red pomodoro cocktail sauce. Either ways this calamari is a good consistent product for those people that like lightly breaded calamari. Squeeze the lemon on it and you are good to go.Â
Â
Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna Appetizer
I figure when I am at a restaurant that specializes in seafood, I have to try their Ahi Tuna if they have it and see how it compares to some other Ahi Tuna dishes I have had around the world.
Right now the restaurant that holds the #1 spot in my books for an Ahi Tuna dish is a place called the Market Street Grill in Salt Lake City, Utah. Trust me, if you like Ahi Tuna and find yourself in Salt Lake City, go out of your way and visit the Market Street Grill. Anyhow, back to the Ahi Tuna at Atlantic Fish.
The Ahi at Atlantic Fish was plated cleanly with 3 fair sized pieces, topped with some freshly chopped ginger and zig zag of thick soya sauce on the plate. I figured that for near $10, 3 pieces of Ahi was a bit cheapo. I would say at least put 4 of 5 pieces on the dish. The red Ahi tuna was fresh, cold, cut easily with a fork and melted in the mouth. This stuff was good. The quick sesame searing on the outside with the ginger a dash of wasabi was a great tasting combination. Was it enough to knock off The Market Street Grill off of my #1 spot? Nope; Market Street still reigns supreme. The Ahi Tuna appetizer here is good and if you have the Ahi Tuna urge, the Ahi at Atlantic Fish will definitely make you happy.Â

Toasted Goat Cheese Salad
I have no idea why I ordered this dish. I think it was my friend ranting and raving about how good this Toasted Goat Cheese Salad dish was. So when our waitress was taking our order, my friend ordered her Goat Cheese Salad, and being caught up in the moment, I also ordered one.
Not a big deal you say? Well, I’m the type of person that doesn’t even like cheese on things except for pizzas and even then I would rather have “easy” cheese. I’m the type of guy that scrapes the cheese off things! I like the salad part, but for me to order a Toasted Goat Cheese Salad was way way way out of the norm.
The salad came to the table with the hunk of toasted goat cheese on the top with roasted golden beets, spiced pecans and fresh organic greens tossed in the light red wine vinaigrette. This salad I have to admit was actually really tasty. I ate up everything except for half the toasted goat cheese. For a non cheese lover, the goat cheese was actually full of flavor and complemented the other ingredients in the salad well. If you like goat cheese you will love this salad.

Apple Crisp
I always like to ask the server to describe and recommend me their favorite dessert. You can usually tell if someone is lying to if they don’t say too much about their favorite dessert. If they go off the rocker, and a twinkle lights up in their eye when they tell you all about their favorite dessert, you know you can’t really go wrong with their suggestion.
Our server this entire evening was awesome. She was sooo funny, had such a great personality, recommended great dishes, gave us top notch service and when it came to dessert time, she told me that one of her favorite desserts was the apple crisp. Some of her others were pie’s. I don’t like pies, but I really really like a good home baked apple crisp. I asked her if the crisp on the apple crisp was “crisp and crunchy” and not soggy like some places. She told me to order it and guaranteed me that if I didn’t like the dish, I could send it back. I was in a no lose situation.
When the apple crisp hit the table, the crisp was still steaming hot, it was crunchy and crisp and I could smell the apples. As for the ice cream on the top…my goodness… to die for. My friend and I polished this Apple Crisp off in record time. The apple slices on the inside of the crisp were baked to perfection. This dish was close to perfection. One of the top 5 apple crisps I have ever had. My server came back when we had about 3 spoonfuls left… I asked if I could send it back as I wasn’t too thrilled..she told me to get lost….

I am glad I went with my friend and had a great dining experience at the Atlantic Fish. I can honestly say if you are in Boston and don’t mind spending the money, but you want a popular and solid seafood restaurant with a great atmosphere, Atlantic Fish would be a great choice.
 
I would make some reservations before hand as this place was packed with a line up at the door the entire time I was here and still when I left the restaurant. I can vouch for the Butternut Squash Soup, the Goat Cheese Salad, and most definitely the Apple Crisp. Yes, get the Apple Crisp. Maybe start your meal with the Apple Crisp, you won’t be disappointed.
Ranking (out of 5 Stars)
Food – 4.00
Service – 4.75
Washroom Cleanliness – 4.25
Restaurant Ambiance – 4.00
Plate/Cutlery Cleanliness – 4.25
Value – 3.75
Overall rating: 4.17